Diverging Priorities Driving the Move to LTE
The communications infrastructure overlaid on the power delivery infrastructure is a key component to providing reliable electric service. Therefore, reliability of grid communications coincides with delivering reliable electric power. Historically, utilities have had to rely on public carriers for many last-mile communications needs. It was simply too expensive to build out that last-mile infrastructure for a single use case. As consumer demand for streaming, virtual reality gaming and other services that require enormous bandwidth has increased, the public carriers have shifted focus to align with customer demand for higher capacity. They are moving away quickly from the low-bandwidth, highly reliable circuits utilities need toward next-generation wireless services available to tens of millions of customers. Utilities are left with a daunting choice: to keep up with the public carrier refresh cycles while fighting public carrier diverging priorities for the ordinary consumer market or to gain control by building out their own networks.
Though carrier 5G service offers the potential for ultra-fast speeds and low latency, utility network planners are becoming increasingly concerned they will not receive priority from the carriers when issues arise. This lack of priority and ability to manage repairs after a natural disaster continues to accentuate the need for utility private networks.
Electric utilities require extensive communications networks along their transmission and distribution lines. On the largest high-voltage lines, for example, end-to-end communication is a necessity to comply with regulatory fault clearing times. If a power line breaks or a fault occurs on any sector, every fraction of a second to isolate and shut off the line matters. A delay beyond even a few milliseconds can result in extensive damage taking months to repair at significant cost. Massive wildfires in California exemplify this need; in 2020, San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) piloted providing low-latency connections to achieve rapid fault clearing. LTE provides the high-speed and low-latency data communications while moving computing to the edge — such as the mid-span of a transmission line — to meet these stringent requirements.
On distribution systems, the one-way power flow has given way to bidirectional flows of energy due to new demands such as distributed solar generation, wind, and electric vehicle charging. The changing distribution grid requires increased automation and control points at significant scale and density, improved system visibility, and a level of network prioritization that the public carriers don’t guarantee. Additionally, utilities are beginning to consider advanced metering applications with the LTE radio embedded into the meter itself. This will require millions of endpoints and capacity that only an industry standards-based network can provide.