The most important consideration for the design of an export terminal is the selection of refrigeration technology. The options are closed-loop and open-loop refrigeration. For liquefied natural gas (LNG), closed-loop refrigeration typically is used because of the product’s refrigeration temperature. For propane, the controlling factor in determining the type of refrigeration design is based on product quality and the possibility of noncondensables. Closed-loop refrigeration systems are more flexible and provide advantages for handling light ends and contaminants; this design requires more equipment and higher operational expenses. In contrast, in an open-loop refrigeration system, the product itself is the cooling medium, so the system requires less equipment. Open-loop refrigeration technology requires less power and equipment but has less flexibility.
If more than one product will be refrigerated and loaded to ships at the terminal, then both open-loop and closed-loop technologies are feasible. The difference in refrigeration temperatures will determine both the design of the system and how the design can be integrated to optimize power consumption. The most common application for open-loop refrigeration technology is for combinations of propane and butane products. In this scenario, the propane product is used to chill the butane product.
The refrigerant compression system selected will vary based on the technology selected. Designers can either select large open art systems that leverage economies of scale or rely on multiple packaged refrigeration systems in parallel. Packaged systems simplify engineering and construction and provide inherent redundancy, but they also offer limited compressor selection and customization and will result in a larger number of individual equipment pieces. The selection of open- or closed-loop configuration often depends on owner preference or the presence or lack of noncondensables. The closed-loop option can be the most flexible, while the open-loop option will result in the lowest power consumption and least amount of equipment.